Tucked away on one of Key West's most private and secluded streetsseriously, if you've never been to 913 Watson Street, you've probably never been on this blockthis meticulously reimagined historic home, built prior to 1912, is the epitome of island living. Located in the coveted Old Town neighborhood and Key West's highest elevation (X-500 Flood Zone), this property seamlessly blends historic charm with modern conveniences. Every inch of this residence, completed in April 2025, has been thoughtfully revitalized with no expense spared. We're talking historic-approved impact-rated windows and sliding doors, a brand-new roof, plumbing, electrical, HVAC, and foundation piers, plus gleaming hardwood floors. Step inside the main house, where you'll find a bright and airy one-bedroom, 1.5-bath layout featuring a stylish kitchen with all-new appliances, a dedicated laundry room, and tranquil garden and pool views. Oversized sliding doors blur the lines between indoor and outdoor living, leading you to a serene outdoor space complete with a saltwater cocktail pool, water feature, and composite deckingideal for al fresco dining, lounging, or simply enjoying the tropical ambiance. Directly across from the main home is the separate guest house, which could serve as a second full bedroom or a spacious living room. This versatile space includes a large walk-in closet, en-suite bathroom, and tranquil pool views, offering both comfort and privacy. The property also features a large carport, offering ample space for parking. And let's talk locationwalking and biking distance to Key West's top restaurants, nightlife, and beaches, yet nestled on a street so private, it feels like a secret.
Details
MLS#
614474
Listing Type
For Sale
Style
House
Sub-Type
Resale
Status
Active
Year
1912
Days On Site
24
Listing Provided By
Truman & Co. (KW) | Team Kaufelt
Features
Bed(s)
2
Bath(s)
3 Total
SQ Feet
1,133
Pool
Yes
Units
2
Zoning
HHDR - Historic High Density Res
Acreage
0.06
Water Front
None
Property View
No Waterview
Market Activity 33040
Date
Sales
Avg $ Per SqFt
Min Sale Price
Max Sale Price
Med Sale Price
Date: Mar 2025
Sales: 11
Avg $ Per SqFt: $506.23
Min Sale Price: $1,100
Max Sale Price: $3,250,000
Med Sale Price: $253,100
Date: Feb 2025
Sales: 10
Avg $ Per SqFt: $851
Min Sale Price: $269,574
Max Sale Price: $3,690,000
Med Sale Price: $770,500
Date: Jan 2025
Sales: 11
Avg $ Per SqFt: $833.98
Min Sale Price: $6,000
Max Sale Price: $3,499,000
Med Sale Price: $800,000
Date: Dec 2024
Sales: 10
Avg $ Per SqFt: $1022.64
Min Sale Price: $183,600
Max Sale Price: $6,500,000
Med Sale Price: $1,400,000
Date: Nov 2024
Sales: 12
Avg $ Per SqFt: $913.29
Min Sale Price: $315,000
Max Sale Price: $2,250,000
Med Sale Price: $974,500
Date: Oct 2024
Sales: 7
Avg $ Per SqFt: $1019.35
Min Sale Price: $340,000
Max Sale Price: $3,243,000
Med Sale Price: $950,000
Date: Sep 2024
Sales: 1
Avg $ Per SqFt: $94.13
Min Sale Price: $133,200
Max Sale Price: $133,200
Med Sale Price: $133,200
Date: Aug 2024
Sales: 3
Avg $ Per SqFt: $588.75
Min Sale Price: $500,000
Max Sale Price: $985,000
Med Sale Price: $815,000
Date: Jul 2024
Sales: 4
Avg $ Per SqFt: $881.41
Min Sale Price: $753,300
Max Sale Price: $1,500,000
Med Sale Price: $1,058,500
Date: Jun 2024
Sales: 6
Avg $ Per SqFt: $902.77
Min Sale Price: $650,000
Max Sale Price: $4,500,000
Med Sale Price: $1,055,000
Date: May 2024
Sales: 6
Avg $ Per SqFt: $813.87
Min Sale Price: $595,000
Max Sale Price: $1,850,000
Med Sale Price: $938,000
Date: Apr 2024
Sales: 6
Avg $ Per SqFt: $854.22
Min Sale Price: $599,000
Max Sale Price: $1,312,500
Med Sale Price: $907,500
Sourced by Back At You
Mar 2025
Sales:
11
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$506.23
Min Sale Price:
$1,100
Max Sale Price:
$3,250,000
Med Sale Price:
$253,100
Feb 2025
Sales:
10
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$851
Min Sale Price:
$269,574
Max Sale Price:
$3,690,000
Med Sale Price:
$770,500
Jan 2025
Sales:
11
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$833.98
Min Sale Price:
$6,000
Max Sale Price:
$3,499,000
Med Sale Price:
$800,000
Dec 2024
Sales:
10
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$1022.64
Min Sale Price:
$183,600
Max Sale Price:
$6,500,000
Med Sale Price:
$1,400,000
Nov 2024
Sales:
12
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$913.29
Min Sale Price:
$315,000
Max Sale Price:
$2,250,000
Med Sale Price:
$974,500
Oct 2024
Sales:
7
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$1019.35
Min Sale Price:
$340,000
Max Sale Price:
$3,243,000
Med Sale Price:
$950,000
Sep 2024
Sales:
1
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$94.13
Min Sale Price:
$133,200
Max Sale Price:
$133,200
Med Sale Price:
$133,200
Aug 2024
Sales:
3
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$588.75
Min Sale Price:
$500,000
Max Sale Price:
$985,000
Med Sale Price:
$815,000
Jul 2024
Sales:
4
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$881.41
Min Sale Price:
$753,300
Max Sale Price:
$1,500,000
Med Sale Price:
$1,058,500
Jun 2024
Sales:
6
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$902.77
Min Sale Price:
$650,000
Max Sale Price:
$4,500,000
Med Sale Price:
$1,055,000
May 2024
Sales:
6
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$813.87
Min Sale Price:
$595,000
Max Sale Price:
$1,850,000
Med Sale Price:
$938,000
Apr 2024
Sales:
6
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$854.22
Min Sale Price:
$599,000
Max Sale Price:
$1,312,500
Med Sale Price:
$907,500
MLS Number: 614474
Team Kaufelt – (305) 393-1267 – teamkaufelt@trumanandcompany.com
MLS Internet Data Exchange (IDX) information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the Florida Keys Board of Realtors.
The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site come s in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the Marathon and Lower Keys Association of REALTORS®, Inc. MLS. Real Estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Schmitt are marked with the MLS logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker’s office.
Request a showing
Request a showing
Loading Form
Listings Checked: 4 minutes ago
MLS Number: 614474
Team Kaufelt – (305) 393-1267 – teamkaufelt@trumanandcompany.com